DISQUS

Largehearted Boy: Largehearted Boy: Contest - Win Nick Hornby's New Novel "Juliet Naked"

  • Dave Siegel · 2 months ago
    There are so many, but I very much liked the original "The Manchurian Candidate" with Frank Sinatra and Angela Lansbury, perhaps a film even better than the novel.
  • Nymeth · 2 months ago
    The Virgin Suicides.
  • Corinne Knapp · 2 months ago
    I'm a sucker for animation so I would say "Jungle Book." But Schindler's Ark (Schindler's List) is up there near the top.
  • Jason · 2 months ago
    Into the Wild
  • jodycollins · 2 months ago
    I would have to say The Shawshank Redemption. Darabont took a decent novella, and turned it into a complete and utter masterpiece of film.
  • saulblacktop · 2 months ago
    East of Eden, although I like the book better :)
  • Bill Persons · 2 months ago
    Old Yeller comes to an old mind.

    Love your site, thanks for exposing me to such good new music.
  • David · 2 months ago
    Does Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory count? Because the story is ok and the book is all right, but I think my childhood and adult sensibilities would be drastically different if not for Gene Wilder's portrayal of the man.
  • Sarah A. · 2 months ago
    East of Eden
  • kristen · 2 months ago
    Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy. It didn't try too hard to be sci-fi and had such well shot scenes.
  • EightE1 · 2 months ago
    Robert Altman's Short Cuts (weaving Raymond Carver's short stories into a wonderful film).
  • DBS · 2 months ago
    Trainspotting
  • Kristin · 2 months ago
    Clueless (as an adaptation of Jane Austen's Emma)? Jaws? I think I have to go with The Shining.
  • Trishofalltrades · 2 months ago
    Well you know what they say.. don't judge a book by its movie.. but.. I'd have to say Ripley's Game. No no, not The Talented Mr. Ripley with Matt Damon, but Ripley's Game with John Malkovich. Although the teen girl in me will sometimes say Clueless (a la Emma). hahaha
  • Sarah · 2 months ago
    The Grapes of Wrath is one of my favorite books and the film is one of my favorite movies, but for very different reasons. Separating the two is important for my enjoyment.
  • Dee · 2 months ago
    The Virgin Suicides
  • Hurdler4eva · 2 months ago
    I really liked The Other Boleyn Girl!
  • JJ Ochwat · 2 months ago
    I was glad they made "Thank You for Smoking" into a movie, but I wish the movie had taken as many risks as the book.
  • monicalee · 2 months ago
    The Grapes of Wrath (1940)
  • grrlgenius · 2 months ago
    "The Devil Wears Prada" because they fixed all the things I hated about the main character in print, besides who can resist Meryl Streep?
  • jamiesrich · 2 months ago
    The first 10 minutes of so of the Burt Lancaster THE KILLERS is a perfect adaptation of the Hemingway short story.
  • aarika · 2 months ago
    "The Godfather" is a really good call. But I am going to have to go with "The Princess Bride" because, hey, still amazing after all these years.
  • conwayk14 · 2 months ago
    "African Queen" - found the film so much better than the novel.
  • amplifiednickie · 2 months ago
    I love the BBC version of Pride and Prejudice, so well done!
  • LibraryKat · 2 months ago
    Restoration was a magnificent movie!
  • tjknight · 2 months ago
    I quite like David Cronenberg's Naked Lunch. The film does a great job with a somewhat un-filmable novel.
  • Chris · 2 months ago
    Margaret Atwood's book The Handmaiden's Tale was nothing like the movie, but both were great... although there were times in the first 8 years of this century that I felt we were about to live the book/movie...
  • Todd · 2 months ago
    A Clockwork Orange
  • WordGirl · 2 months ago
    I think The Time Traveler's Wife was a good adaptation of a complex book - it stayed true to the spirit of the book without being hokey.

    The worst may be City of Ember - although our whole family ripped through the book only to watch the movie this afternoon with underwhelming results
  • Shannon · 2 months ago
    My favorite: Catch Me If You Can!
  • Priscilla · 2 months ago
    The adaptation of Michael Chabon's "Wonder Boys," and also two treatments of Raymond Carver's work, "Short Cuts" and "Jindabyne," an interesting adaptation of "So Much Water So Close to Home."
  • Matt · 2 months ago
    Loved Jesus' Son, got me turned on to to the author Denis Johnson, Billy Crudup is great, and this was a tough adaption since the book is collection of short stories yet the movie is able to bring the stories into one narrative.
  • Drew · 2 months ago
    Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas
  • boyhowdy · 2 months ago
    Oddly, I find I liked the Tim Burton cinematic version of James and the Giant Peach more than any other film adaptation. It's not terribly deep, but it frames the movie exceptionally well as a movie, without making shit up beyond the original, exceptional book.

    Yeah, the original and remake of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory are good, too.
  • berwyn100 · 2 months ago
    After Midnight by Sidney Sheldon was a movie I enjoyed after reading the book. This was a made for TV movie.
  • maria215 · 2 months ago
    I just love Everything Is Illuminate both book and film.
  • patbicks · 2 months ago
    The English Patient
  • goose98 · 2 months ago
    I have a few in mind, but I have to go with American Psycho.
  • molly · 2 months ago
    Quite clearly: the original "Anne of Green Gables", circa 1985. Terrific.
  • Jennifer Miller · 2 months ago
    I think my favorite book to film adaptation was "Wonder Boys"; I really enjoy Chabon's writing, and the book was great...but the film was that much better.
  • Jessie · 2 months ago
    How about the Big Sleep? Originally a novel by Raymond Chandler, great film noir movie.
  • iams · 2 months ago
    I'm from Sweden, can I enter anyway? I'll try.

    My favourite is "Revolutionary road" because such an amazing novel turned into such an amazing movie.
  • Georgia S · 2 months ago
    I have to say a Love Song for Bobby Long because the movie (which I saw first) was 5 million times better than the book. Good music in it too.
  • Fred von Lohmann · 2 months ago
    The Unbearable Lightness of Being. For sure.
  • LJ · 2 months ago
    There definitely are some great adaptations to choose from but I think the BBC's Pride and Prejudice does an exceptionally precise job of translating a classic piece of literature into film.... much to the dread of boyfriends and high school English classes the world over. :)
  • Adam · 2 months ago
    Wonder Boys just makes me so happy.
  • Shawn · 2 months ago
    Jaws. The book is a mediocre melodrama, with a dash of horror thrown in. The film, on the other hand, is one of the most terrifying in the history of cinema.
  • Shawn · 2 months ago
    Jaws. The book is a mediocre melodrama, with a dash of horror thrown in. The film, on the other hand, is one of the most terrifying in the history of cinema.
  • Kenneth Coble · 2 months ago
    Les Miserables.

    That story is magic in ANY format.
  • Name · 2 months ago
    Love "About the Boy"!
    P
  • Floyd · 2 months ago
    It would have to be Sophie's Choice. . .a work of fiction in my "Top Five" and I believe a fine film adaptation.
  • douglascuba · 2 months ago
    How about "The Hours" written by Michael Cunningham about Virginia Woolf and her book "Mrs Dalloway", and adapted for film by Stephen Daldry (screenplay by David Hare) and starring Nicole Kidman, Meryl Streep and Julianne Moore? Wonderful soundtrack by Philip Glass.

    Another would be "The Dead" a short story written by James Joyce and adapted for film by John Huston, starring Angelica Huston and the great Irish actor Donal McCann.
  • Brian · 2 months ago
    Sean Penn's adaptation of Krakauer's "Into the Wild"
  • esseff · 2 months ago
    The Color Purple
  • Connie · 2 months ago
    The Exorcist comes to mind.
  • Brian B. · 2 months ago
    The Ice Storm
  • Holli · 2 months ago
    I'm not a big fan of most adaptations, so I'll go with a classic - Gone With The Wind.
  • Chris Campbell · 2 months ago
    The Grapes of Wrath
  • Christina · 2 months ago
    It just so happens to be one of my favorite movies: The BBC (America) version of Pride & Prejudice with Colin Firth. It has to be this version. I could watch it multiple times over and never get tired of it.
  • Kevin · 2 months ago
    The Outsiders, there is just something about Pony Boy and the whole cast in bringing my favourite middle school book to life.
  • JDS · 2 months ago
    Definitely "The Long Goodbye." While Altman made a lot of changes to the story it is not only my favorite film adaptation of a Raymond Chandler novel, but my favorite adaptation of any novel.
  • coffeefortwo · 2 months ago
    No Country For Old Men
  • rupe33 · 2 months ago
    LA CONFIDENTIAL by James Ellroy. Despite the fact that the last third of the movie deviates nearly totally from the book, it still holds up as its own film while maintaining both a respect and the feel of the original material.
  • Mary · 2 months ago
    The first one that came to mind immediately was "The Princess Bride." But I think that had to do with Goldman writing the screenplay as well...

    But on a much deeper and memorable level, the old BBC version of "Brideshead Revisited," with odd frames and gaffs and all.
  • Corey V. · 2 months ago
    You've already mentioned it. High Fidelity.
  • Darren · 2 months ago
    'the princess bride"
  • tomdabomb · 2 months ago
    Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas and It.
  • ikkinlala · 2 months ago
    The Shawshank Redemption.
  • Mark Dysart · 2 months ago
    One Flew Over the Cookoo's Nest is one of my favorite books that also was a wonderful movie.
  • paulehoffman · 2 months ago
    The Handmaid's Tale.
  • Robert Loy · 2 months ago
    Ordinarily, I wish Hollywood would leave my favorite books alone. That said, I think the movie version of Neil Gaiman's Stardust was better than the book and the book was magnificent.
  • John · 2 months ago
    "The Friends of Eddie Coyle." Great book, great film, the latter now out on DVD for the first time.
  • Winston · 2 months ago
    No Country For Old Men has been the adaptation I was most impressed with thus far.

    I'm hoping that the loose adaptation of Where The Wild Things Are blows me away though.
  • Sophia · 2 months ago
    The Color Purple successfully made a film adaptation as riveting as the book that inspired it.
  • johnrasmussen · 2 months ago
    Night Watch by Sergei Lukyanenko
  • Jeff P · 2 months ago
    To Kill a Mockingbird
  • Rob Terry · 2 months ago
    "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest." One of the few times for me where the film adaptation equals or exceeds the book.
  • Cee · 2 months ago
    I love Dodie Smith's I Capture the Castle, and thought the movie did fairly well at capturing the spirit of the brilliant, quirky book.
  • ryan97ou · 2 months ago
    i would have to agree with American Psycho
  • lindseygrad · 2 months ago
    to kill a mockingbird. impossible to decide if i love harper lee or gregory peck more. and scout was spot on.
  • rayorkwis · 2 months ago
    My favorite film adaptation was one that was never made. Just the idea of it was perplexing and intriguing. I speak of the film that Alan Rudolph was going to make from *The Far Side.*

    (from http://www.filmfreakcentral.net/diff/arudolphin...)

    You've often spoken of an adaptation of Gary Larson's "The Far Side" comic one-panel.
    AR: Oh, I almost got that made. David Putnam almost made that at Columbia for the half-hour that he was there. (laughs) Now you'd probably do it totally different, but at the time we'd done the test and it was really funny. It looked just like the cartoon--Gary is a friend and I just took his three or four hundred panels and had some kind of story about the struggle for reality by humans and anything not human. So spiders had as big a part as the two goofy people with the hair, y'know.
  • Stephanie N · 2 months ago
    I truly enjoyed all three Lord of the Rings movies. They were well done.
  • sweetktastr0phe8 · 2 months ago
    Requiem for a Dream
  • Brent Dotson · 2 months ago
    Jurassic Park
  • PartyPeople · 2 months ago
    The Devil Wears Prada - The film was funnier and sweeter than the brittle novel.
  • vjb77 · 2 months ago
    Bladerunner.
  • banjoboy · 2 months ago
    "Terms of Endearment". The movie got rid of all the excess baggage of the book.
  • Nate · 2 months ago
    Lonesome Dove, people.
  • Nate · 2 months ago
    Lonesome Dove, people.
  • nagra178a · 2 months ago
    Basketball Diaries
  • Renee C · 2 months ago
    Anne of Green Gables.
  • wildflower00 · 2 months ago
    Wuthering Heights
  • G · 2 months ago
    Blade Runner, for the artistic departures from the source material.
  • kazul · 2 months ago
    Has to be Stanley Kubrick's The Shining - The Stephen King book still creeps me out with every re-read and the movie scares me over and over.
  • Bret · 2 months ago
    The Princess Bride came to mind first...
  • nevillethompson · 2 months ago
    The adaption that I most liked in recent years was Peter Jackson adaption of Lord of the Rings.

    Despite the vast canvas the series covers, I think he did an amazing series of films that really captured the books for a new audience.
  • patwagner · 2 months ago
    Jaws. So-So book excellent movie.
  • dglitter · 2 months ago
    Here's an oldie but a goodie-Planet of the Apes-the original one.
  • raelena · 2 months ago
    Into the Wild. The book is amazing and so is the movie. It had everyone in tears!
  • Jana · 2 months ago
    The Neverending Story and Little Women were both much more enjoyable in film form.
  • carollawrence · 2 months ago
    My choice is Jaws.
  • roseh2o19 · 2 months ago
    slaughterhouse 5
  • Carolyn · 2 months ago
    The Hours
  • Andrew Watson · 2 months ago
    I'll go along with The Shining.

    And I'll offer the observation: given the choice, see the movie before reading the book on which it's based. Otherwise, you risk the "What are they doing to the book in my head" and "How could they leave out..." reactions drowning out other responses to the movie.

    Case in point: I was very disappointed with the movie of One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It was nowhere near, and nowhere near as good as, the novel I'd read before.
  • Miranda · 2 months ago
    I know some people will glare at me for this opinion - but I really enjoyed the movie adaptation of Twilight. The book is young and naive and the movie is so "B" with the special effects yet raw emotions it kinda fits! LOL
  • Jon · 2 months ago
    Schindler's List
  • marksiegel · 2 months ago
    Children of Men
  • Melissa D · 2 months ago
    S.E. Hinton's teen angst classic THE OUTSIDERS, which gets even better with time.
  • virgomomwriter · 2 months ago
    Dangerous Liaisons, hands down.
  • Lucas · 2 months ago
    Jurassic Park all the way!
  • The J Train · 2 months ago
    Appropriately enough for the contest, I'd have to go with High Fidelity.
  • Pat Babcock · 2 months ago
    The Harry Potter films are so true to the books
  • Alicia Webster · 2 months ago
    I loved The Shining. (The original movie with Jack Nicholson, not that horrendous monstrosity that was made for TV.)And even though I am a fan of Stephen King, I have to say that I think the Nicholson version of The Shining was BETTER than the book. But that's just my opinion.
  • Chris B · 2 months ago
    "About A Boy" - read on the verge of parenthood, saw the movie as a parent... all good.
  • jung · 2 months ago
    Factotum.

    Bent Hamer's take on Bukowski trumps the amusing-yet-flawed Barfly.
  • krstrpp · 2 months ago
    I enjoyed the movie "House of Sand and Fog" more than the book. For some reason, I just never got into the characters in the book, but the great actors pulled it off. Definitely a rarity. Thanks for the chance to win Nick Hornby's latest novel.
  • mindy · 2 months ago
    amityville horror
  • ky2here · 2 months ago
    Johnny Got His Gun - dalton trumbo should have been proud.
  • Katie · 2 months ago
    The Princess Bride for sure. The movie is amazing. :)
  • Devan · 2 months ago
    _O Brother, Where Art Thou?_ (Coen, 2000). Adaptation from one medium to another should take substantial liberties to suit the expectations of the new medium's audience. _O Brother…_ is _The Odyssey_, but it is grounded in techniques and devices specific to film.
  • Nico · 2 months ago
    Hideous Kinky
  • Jennifer · 2 months ago
    Children of Men. The book and film are very different, so I tend to think of them as separate entities - but the film on its own merits is flawless.
  • Fernando · 2 months ago
    "The Empire of the Sun". Because I would never have guessed that Spielberg would be the right director for a Ballard book, and yet he was.
  • Grant · 2 months ago
    The Virgin Suicides. I found the book so bland. Sofia Coppola took the story and made it something completely hearfelt - great soundtrack, too.
  • ken krimstein · 2 months ago
    The Bible. C. B. DeMille -- you know what i'm sayin?
  • demko · 2 months ago
    The Van
  • Adam · 2 months ago
    Awesome!
  • Adam · 2 months ago
    Harry Potter, of course!
  • Sam · 2 months ago
    Adaptation

    And because that might not quite qualify as an adaptation, The Shawshank Redemption.
  • Heather · 2 months ago
    Memoirs of a Geisha is one of my favorite book/movie adaptations.
  • Adam Burke · 2 months ago
    Not trying to suck up here but I would have to agree with your post and say 'High Fidelity' is my 1st choice...what a wonderful film...
  • Doug Harder · 2 months ago
    Wow there are so many great choices. I have to go with The Lord OF The Rings trilogy. Just because I didn't believe it was possible to do the book justice. It sucked that they didn't include Tom Bombadil though. Thanks for the great contest.
  • Del · 2 months ago
    Trainspotting. That was a no-brainer for me.
  • danen · 2 months ago
    "The Green Mile," perhaps equally "The Shawshank Redemption."
  • partyweetow · 2 months ago
    The only book-to-movie adaptation where I like the movie better is Tuck Everlasting. My favorite adaptation, though, would probably be Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. The book was beyond awesome, and the movie was pretty good. By far the best movie of the series so far. I'm thinking the last two movies are going to be awesome as well.
  • SacredSpud · 2 months ago
    Adaptation/The Orchid Thief.
  • Jeff · 2 months ago
    High Fidelity
  • jasonnickolay · 2 months ago
    I am going with "The Green Mile"

    jason(at)allworldautomotive(dot)com
  • haley · 2 months ago
    Revolutionary Road, very true to the book. & very excited for Where the Wild Things Are
  • wwe11 · 2 months ago
    I love Twilight.
  • christopher h · 2 months ago
    the postman -- no, really, the story works in the film version better than the book
  • Ed Nemmers · 2 months ago
    "V For Vendetta"!
  • Phyllis Lamken · 2 months ago
    Best adaptation of a book to a movie...Lord of the Rings triology.
  • Chrysa · 2 months ago
    I'm usually disappointed with movies from novels, but I actually liked "The Witches of Eastwick"
  • AICORP · 2 months ago
    it's kind of trite but I like Tolkien's Return of the King adaptation.
  • fresnosummer · 2 months ago
    i'm probably throwing myself under the bus with this one, but I thought the "Watchmen" film was great. sure there wasn't a monster at the end, but i think the change was necessary to soldify the seriousness of the subject matter.
  • thomas gerusky · 2 months ago
    Gone with the Wind
  • Bradley B. · 2 months ago
    Searching for Bobby Fischer. One of the few book/movie combos where the movie was better.
  • betty_ny · 2 months ago
    Clueless -- a dead-on update of Emma.
  • MsRedPen · 2 months ago
    The Lord of the Rings films.
  • Nathan · 2 months ago
    2001: A Space Odyssey
  • Eric Bath · 2 months ago
    This Boy's Life and A Home at the End of the World are two of my favorites
  • Dixie · 2 months ago
    One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest will always be one of my favorites.
  • dorothy l · 2 months ago
    one flew over the cuckoos nest
  • Adam · 2 months ago
    The Ice Storm
  • pamelas · 2 months ago
    Mine is "My Dog Skip" believe it or not. I cried and cried (and still do cry) every time I watched that movie. I loved that movie. Thanks.
  • DanV · 2 months ago
    I most enjoyed Lord of the Rings: Return of the King
  • Susan Smith · 2 months ago
    Into the Wild
  • Dwight Harvey · 2 months ago
    I think I'm one of those people for whom High Fidelity is a cultural touchstone, but I'll go with Tristram Shandy: A Cock and Bull Story.
  • AGC · 2 months ago
    Election by Tom Perrotta
  • nat dykeman · 2 months ago
    L.A Confidential.
  • Joshwuh · 2 months ago
    The Secret Garden
  • Buffy · 2 months ago
    Fight Club!
  • Mary · 2 months ago
    Julie & Julia... mmmmm.....
  • Anne · 2 months ago
    Cold Mountain
  • Justin Z. · 2 months ago
    Fight Club
  • Sand · 2 months ago
    I really loved The Kite Runner and thought that the movie stayed true to the book.
  • kerri69 · 2 months ago
    I loved the notebook I thought the movie was greatly done
  • garrettsambo · 2 months ago
    I loved Cold Mountain. garrettsambo@aol.com
  • garrettsambo · 2 months ago
    I loved Cold Mountain. garrettsambo@aol.com
  • garrettsambo · 2 months ago
    I loved Cold Mountain.
  • garrettsambo · 2 months ago
    I loved Cold Mountain.
  • garrettsambo · 2 months ago
    I loved Cold Mountain.
  • rahul · 2 months ago
    Perfume. just loved the way it was done.
  • gkran · 2 months ago
    Dead Poet Society.